TV World

Your favorite shows, new episodes, recaps, transcripts, and spoilers

You are here

Legend of the Seeker: Walter

Replies

Anonymous's picture
Submitted by Anonymous on

I enjoyed the episode but I wouldn't give it a 5.  Craig Parker, however, was excellent and I was very happy to see how versatile he is.  Vengeance was a better episode for me.  

msarko's picture
Submitted by msarko on

I suppose I should explain the admittedly subjective episode rating system. I generally consider an episode a 5 unless there is something that should have been there but wasn't. Every series is judged on its own merits, so where Seeker is concerned, I usually take points off for plot holes, annoying characters, clumsy scripting, etc. While I definitely wouldn't call "Walter" the best of the season, it did what it set out to do proficiently, plus it provided some interesting moments that were unique to the rest of the series.

Matthew L.'s picture
Submitted by Matthew L. on

Speaking of plot holes, in Resurrection an extremely rare elixir was needed to bring a person's spirit back from the underworld, but in this episode they bring two spirits back with just the incantation. I found this oversight especially egregious because of all the throwback lines to previous episodes, but also because Rahl's return wasn't even possible within the confines of the show's own universe, at least in the way it was done.

Another thing that bothered me was how the slave girl was so easily able to break Walter out of the dungeon and then escape. Why hadn't she escaped so much sooner if her whereabouts were being monitored so carelessly, if at all?

While I liked the overall events of this episode, the episode itself was poorly written for the most part. It's a shame that the writing this season has taken such a swift downturn, but I have hope that the writers will redeem themselves next episode. Here's hoping, anyway.

msarko's picture
Submitted by msarko on

Honestly, I totally forgot about the elixir. Nice catch. As for the slave's escape, I'm willing to chalk that up to the commotion of the night. She did poison the two guards and it didn't take long for the horsemen to catch up with her and Walter, so the escape wasn't all that successful anyway.

As for the quality of the writing in the second season, I think it's overall a lot stronger than the first season. It should be noted that we haven't had to endure any annoying child characters or pointless "comedy" episodes. Even this season's clip episode was better.

Necros's picture
Submitted by Necros on

That was just some sorcerer, let's assume someone not too expensive that Denna managed to hire. Sister Tyra was a Sister of the Dark, so I'm guessing she didn't need an elixir to bring back a soul.

About the escape. Mika knew the place inside and out, she must've been there for a long time. But trying to escape on her own was out of the question. First of all, she was too afraid and she was right about it, they cought up to them pretty quickly this time too. And she would've also been alone, without any money, at least she had a roof over her head and some food in the temple. Last but not least she was a slave, perhaps she wouldn't have thought about doing something like this if it was just for her.

 

"The cast of Seeker is far from weak"

You're right about that, Tabrett deserves an Emmy nomination!

Matthew L.'s picture
Submitted by Matthew L. on

But if I recall correctly the Keeper was surprised that someone was taking souls from his domain, though I haven't watched that episode in a while.

Also, I agree that the writing this season has been much stronger than last, but in my opinion the past few episodes have taken a nosedive in that regard. Usually I wouldn't concern myself with a few subpar episodes, it happens with every series, but I fear that this may be the last season and as such would like for it to go out with a bang if that is indeed the case.

msarko's picture
Submitted by msarko on

You are unfortunately spot-on about Legend of the Seeker not lasting. Reports came out just today that the show has lost most of its distribution and there haven't been any takers for a proposed third season. It seems that Sam Raimi has put his attention to Sparticus: Blood and Sand, which isn't a surprise. If I were a TV producer, I wouldn't be enthusiastic about my expensive UHF show living in a weekend slot purgatory.

Leave a Reply

Filtered HTML

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <ul> <ol> <li> <i> <b> <img> <table> <tr> <td> <th> <div> <strong> <p> <br> <u>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.